Thread: Trying to understand the Pokewalker

God help me. I have walked 6600 steps with my Machop through the Rugged Road and obtained 360 Watts, so that's 36 turns on the Poke Radar, according to serebii I should have a 50% chance of finding a Magby as my Machop is fighting type and I've done over 5000 steps. Yet on all 36 tries I didn't get a single Magby. I find this impossible to believe and now severly doubt what Serebii says can anyone try and explain this to me, I doubt this is down to bad luck, I also didn't see any Ponyta's which I was also trying to find and no Geodude's either.

Sorry, all you will find then are Onix, Machop, and Hoot Hoot. You only get three pokemon per stroll.

So if I returned from stroll, then sent the same Pokemon back, then the Pokemon that appear would be different?

Some should differ, yes, however some will probably be the same, and it's not certain that will change, but it is the only way to change.

TL;DR, yes.