I would pick Erika. She's very elegant and you know she smells great, and plus perfume is one of the few areas where I'm really girly so I'd love dating someone who makes it herself. She could give me a signature scent!
As for her sexual orientation matching mine, I have no doubts. I mean, I don't know what other conclusion you could reach with that all-girls, no-boys-allowed gym of hers... and the way that one guy in front of it was so mysterious fascinated by it... you KNOW what that means. She's basically confirming it by giving out the RAINBOW Badge.