Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst - Page 3

Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 31 to 45 of 47
Like Tree7Likes

Thread: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

  1. #31
    Raspberry Pi user. Galactic's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Gender
    Uncertain
    Location
    PokéMet Office
    Posts
    180

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    I have never liked Piplup or its evolution.



    If I play Gen IV, I would have to choose Turtwig as the best, probably Piplup at the bottom. Gen V would be Oshawott at the top and Snivy at the bottom.

    I couldn't really give a full list from one to ten as I have only played Gen 4 and 5.
    Team: Castform; Klinklang; Victini; Tornadus

  2. #32
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    131

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    First stage:
    1. Snivy
    2. Fenniken
    3. Charmander
    4. Tododile
    5. Squirtle
    6. Bulbasaur
    7. Chikarita
    8. Froakie
    9. Treecko
    10. Chimchar
    11. Torchic
    12. Mudkip
    13. Cyndaquil
    14. Turtwig
    15. Tepig
    16. Chespin
    17. Piplup
    18. Oshawott

    Second Stage:
    1. Dewott
    2. Monferno
    3. Wartortle
    4. Charmeleon
    5. Ivysaur
    6. Combusken
    7. Bayleaf
    8. Quilava
    9. Servine
    10. Croconaw
    11. Grotle
    12. Grovyle
    13. Marshtomp
    14. Prinplup
    15. Pignite

    Third Stage
    1. Serperior
    2. Feraligatr
    3. Blaziken
    4. Charizard
    5. Infernape
    6. Torterra
    7. Blastoise
    8. Venusaur
    9. Empoleon
    10. Typhlosion
    11. Samurott
    12. Sceptile
    13. Meganium
    14. Swampert
    15. Emboar

  3. #33
    The Deceiver Pokemon Team Gaara's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    The Sand Village
    Posts
    1,528
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    First Stage:
    1. Eevee
    2. Pikachu
    3. Chimchar
    4. Charmander
    5. Cyndaquil
    6. Torchic
    7. Fennekin
    8. Mudkip
    9. Chespin
    10. Froakie
    11. Squirtle
    12. Oshawott
    13. Treecko
    14. Snivy
    15. Tepig
    16. Piplup
    17. Totodile
    18. Chikorita
    19. Bulbasaur
    20. Turtwig

    Second Stage:
    1. Quilava
    2. Bayleef
    3. Grovyle
    4. Dewott
    5. Monferno
    6. Combusken
    7. Charmeleon
    8. Wartortle
    9. Croconaw
    10. Servine
    11. Marshtomp
    12. Prinplup
    13. Ivysaur
    14. Pignite
    15. Grotle

    Third Stage:
    1. Charizard
    2. Blaziken
    3. Infernape
    4. Swampert
    5. Blastoise
    6. Sceptile
    7. Typhlosion
    8. Feraligatr
    9. Samurott
    10. Empoleon
    11. Torterra
    12. Venusaur
    13. Meganium
    14. Serperior
    15. Emboar

  4. #34
    Electrifyingly Adorable Sakuraa's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    Konohagakure
    Posts
    545

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    First Stage
    1. Squirtle
    2. Treecko
    3. Torchic
    4. Chimchar
    5. Charmander
    6. Chikorita
    7. Totodile
    8. Cyndaquil
    9. Pikachu
    10. Oshawott
    11. Bulbasaur
    12. Mudkip
    13. Fennekin
    14. Chespin
    15. Piplup
    16. Turtwig
    17. Snivy
    18. Froakie
    19. Tepig

    Second Stage
    1. Grovyle
    2. Dewott
    3. Monferno
    4. Croconaw
    5. Quilava
    6. Bayleef
    7. Charmeleon
    8. Servine
    9. Wartortle
    10. Combusken
    11. Marshtomp
    12. Ivysaur
    13. Prinplup
    14. Grotle
    15. Pignite

    Final Stage
    1. Blastoise
    2. Sceptile
    3. Blaziken
    4. Charizard
    5. Infernape
    6. Typhlosion
    7. Meganium
    8. Feraligatr
    9. Samurott
    10. Swampert
    11. Venusaur
    12. Torterra
    13. Empoleon
    14. Serperior
    15. Emboar

  5. #35
    Registered User treats's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    21

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    1st stage
    1. Charmander
    2. Treecko
    3. Chikorita
    4. Snivy
    5. Totodile
    6. Mudkip
    7. Fennekin
    8. Oshawott
    9. Torchic
    10. Chespin
    11. Cyndaquil
    12. Tepig
    12. Squirtle
    14. Bulbasaur
    15. Piplup
    16. Turtwig
    17. Chimchar
    18. Froakie

    2nd stage
    1. Wartortle
    2. Charmeleon
    3. Grovyle
    4. Bayleef
    5. Quilava
    6. Servine
    7. Dewott
    8. Marshtomp
    9. Combusken
    10. Croconaw
    11. Ivysaur
    12. Prinplup
    13. Pignite
    14. Grotle
    15. Monferno

    3rd stage
    1. Meganium
    2. Serperior
    3. Charizard
    4. Feraligatr
    5. Samurott
    6. Sceptile
    7. Empoleon
    8. Swampert
    9. Infernape
    10. Typhlosion
    11. Blaziken
    12. Torterra
    13. Emboar
    14. Venusaur
    15. Blastoise

  6. #36
    The Darkest Magikarp Karpi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    933
    Blog Entries
    17

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    I'm just going to rate the overall evolutionary lines...

    1. Mudkip line (Mudkip is cute, Marshtomp is awesome, Swampert is a monster)
    2. Bulbasaur line (Bulbasaur is cute, Ivysaur is awesome, Venusaur is a monster)
    3. Chikorita line (Chikorita is cute, Bayleef is pretty awesome, Meganium is ok)
    4. Torchic line (Torchic is cute, Combusken is pretty awesome, Blaziken is pretty monstrous)
    5. Treecko line (Treecko is pretty cute, Grovyle is awesome, Sceptile is pretty monstrous)
    6. Tepig line (Tepig is cute, Pignite is ok, Emboar is atrociously awful) Note that Tepig's cuteness makes up for a lot
    7. Squirtle line (Squirtle is ok, Wartortle is pretty awesome, Blastoise is pretty monstrous)
    8. Charmander line (Charmander is ok, Charmeleon is pretty awesome, Charizard is pretty monstrous)
    9. Totodile line (Totodile is ok, Croconaw is ok, Feraligatr is pretty monstrous)
    10. Cyndaquil line (Cyndaquil is cute, Quilava is pretty cool, Typhlosion is ok)
    11. Turtwig line (Turtwig is ok, Grotle is ok, Torterra is pretty monstrous)
    12. Piplup line (Piplup is ok, Prinplup is ok, Empoleon is pretty monstrous)
    13. Chimchar line (Chimchar is ok, Monferno is ok, Infernape is pretty monstrous)
    14. Oshawott line (Oshawott is ok, Dewott is ok, Samurott is ok)
    15. Snivy line (Snivy is ok, Servine is dumb, Serperior is weaker than Arbok wtf and it doesn't look threatening either)

    10-14 are basically interchangeable, though. I don't really have strong feelings regarding them. Marshtomp, Ivysaur, and Chikorita are the ones I associate with myself using.



  7. #37
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Posts
    1

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    This was difficult for me because I grew up loving gen. 1&2, but over time I have played ruby, sapphire, emerald, platinum and others. I am basically going to
    judge the pokemon on looks, movesets, and how much I liked them in the anime because I love the anime

    First Stage:
    1. Bulbasaur
    2. Treecko
    3. Squirtle
    4. Chimchar
    5. Totodile
    6. Charmander
    7. Turtwig
    8. Oshawott
    9. Mudkip
    10. Snivy
    11. Chikorita
    12. Cyndaquil
    13. Piplup
    14. Torchic
    15. Tepig

    Its hard to judge these pokemon by anything other than looks because all of their movesets are rather weak at this point.

    Second Stage:
    1. Grovyle
    2. Monferno
    3. Charmeleon
    4. Bayleef
    5. Combusken
    6. Grotle
    7. Dewott
    8. Ivysaur
    9. Marshtomp
    10. Wartortle
    11. Quilava
    12. Servine
    13. Croconaw
    14. Pignite
    15. Prinplup

    Gen 5 easily had the worst starters when judging by the looks. 7-11 are all basically tied but they are in their spots mainly on how much i liked them in the games.

    Third Stage:
    1. Charizard
    2. Infernape
    3. Sceptile
    4. Blastoise
    5. Blaziken
    6. Torterra
    7. Empoleon
    8. Meganium
    9. Swampert
    10. Venusaur
    11. Feraligatr
    12. Typhlosion
    13. Samurott
    14. Emboar
    15. Serperior

    I was so disgusted with the way the gen 5 fully evolved starters looked. All three of them are incredibly weird. gen 2 are a little weak too. Gen 4 and Gen 3 are really really good and Gen 1 is what it is

  8. #38
    Prince of the Sea dirkac's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Crazy Town, Land of Insanity
    Posts
    39

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    Um, alright, then.

    First Stage
    1. Piplup
    2. Torchic
    3. Chikorita
    4. Fennekin
    5. Turtwig
    6. Snivy
    7. Cyndaquil
    8. Froakie
    9. Mudkip
    10. Oshawott
    11. Bulbasaur
    12. Squirtle
    13. Treecko
    14. Totodile
    15. Charmander
    16. Chespin
    17. Tepig
    18. Chimchar (Go. Die. Now. Shoo)

    Middle Stage
    1. Bayleef
    2. Prinplup
    3. Combusken
    4. Grotle
    5. Servine
    6. Quilava
    7. Marshtomp
    8. Braixen
    9. Frogadier
    10. Grovyle
    11. Ivysaur
    12. Dewott
    13. Croconaw
    14. Wartortle
    15. Charmeleon
    16. Quilladin
    17. Pignite
    18. Monferno (Go. Die. Now. Shoo)

    Final Stage
    1. Empoleon
    2. Blaziken
    3. Meganium
    4. Delphox
    5. Torterra
    6. Serperior
    7. Typhlosion
    8. Greninja
    9. Swampert
    10. Venusaur
    11. Sceptile
    12. Feraligatr
    13. Samurott
    14. Blastoise
    15. Chesnaught
    16. Emboar
    17. Charizard
    18. Infernape (Go. Die. Now. Shoo)


    Basically I hate the Chimchar line.
    Herbizarre likes this.

  9. #39
    Registered User DasManiac's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Holly Springs, NC
    Posts
    144
    Blog Entries
    3

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    First Stage:

    1. Treecko
    2. Mudkip
    3. Oshawott
    4. Bulbasaur
    5. Chepsin
    6. Charmander
    7. Piplup
    8. Squirtle
    9. Chikorita
    10. Torchic
    11. Cyndaquil
    12. Totodile
    13. Chimchar
    14. Snivy
    15. Tepig
    16. Froakie
    17. Fennekin
    18. Turtwig

    Second Stage:

    1. Dewott
    2. Grovyle
    3. Croconaw
    4. Bayleef
    5. Charmeleon
    6. Quilladin
    7. Monferno
    8. Wartortle
    9. Ivysaur
    10. Marshtomp
    11. Quilava
    12. Prinplup
    13. Braixen
    14. Frogadier
    15. Servine
    16. Combusken
    17. Pignite
    18. Grotle

    Final Stage:
    It's interesting to see how I'm one of the few people who really liked Emboar and Samurott.

    1. Emboar
    2. Sceptile
    3. Blastoise
    4. Samurott
    5. Chesnaught
    6. Swampert
    7. Feraligatr
    8. Infernape
    9. Meganium
    10. Venasaur
    11. Charizard
    12. Typhlosion
    13. Greninja
    14. Serperior (Design wise I'd rank Serperior in the Top 5 but it's useless in battle)
    15. Empoleon
    16. Torterra
    17. Blaziken
    18. Delphox

    Fennekin had a lot of potential but was completely squandered by its hideous evolutions. The same goes for Torchic. Blaziken has great offensive power but its defenses are so pitifully weak that if you miss an attack, it's gone for.
    Last edited by DasManiac; 8th January 2014 at 07:25 PM.
    FC is 1263 7145 9704 and Name is Drew. Also Charizard is underrated.

  10. #40
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    131

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    First stage:
    1. Snivy
    2. Fenniken
    3. Charmander
    4. Tododile
    5. Squirtle
    6. Bulbasaur
    7. Chikarita
    8. Froakie
    9. Treecko
    10. Chimchar
    11. Torchic
    12. Mudkip
    13. Cyndaquil
    14. Turtwig
    15. Tepig
    16. Chespin
    17. Piplup
    18. Oshawott

    Second Stage:
    1. Frogadier
    2. Dewott
    3. Braixen
    4. Wartortle
    5. Charmeleon
    6. Monferno
    7. Ivysaur
    8. Combusken
    9. Bayleaf
    10. Quilava
    11. Servine
    12. Croconaw
    13. Grotle
    14. Grovyle
    15. Marshtomp
    16. Prinplup
    17. Pignite
    18. Quilladin

    Third Stage
    1. Serperior
    2. Greninja
    3. Feraligatr
    4. Blaziken
    5. Charizard
    6. Infernape
    7. Delphox
    8. Blastoise
    9. Venusaur
    10. Torterra
    11. Empoleon
    12. Typhlosion
    13. Samurott
    14. Sceptile
    15. Meganium
    16. Swampert
    17. Emboar
    18. Chesnaught
    3DS Friend Code: 1993-8025-8352

  11. #41
    Master Exploder GastonGibus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    The Moshpit
    Posts
    708
    Blog Entries
    26

    Follow GastonGibus on Tumblr Visit GastonGibus's Youtube Channel

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    Look, up in the sky! It's a bird, it's a plane, no! It's Unpopular Opinion Man!

    Alright, here's my lists. Starting with first forms from least favorite to most favorite. This is factoring in typing and looks, not as much stats or move-pools.

    18. Fennekin
    17. Chikorita
    16. Tepig
    15. Oshawott
    14. Charmander
    13. Cyndaquil
    12. Chimchar
    11. Torchic
    10. Totodile
    9. Piplup
    8. Chespin
    7. Turtwig
    6. Mudkip
    5. Squirtle
    4. Bulbasaur
    3. Froakie
    2. Snivy
    1. Treecko

    Seconds forms:

    18. Braixen
    17. Quilladin
    16. Pignite
    15. Charmeleon
    14. Combusken
    13. Monferno
    12. Croconaw
    11. Quilava
    10. Grovyle
    9. Bayleef
    8. Dewott
    7. Prinplup
    6. Servine
    5. Marshtomp
    4. Wartortle
    3. Grotle
    2. Ivysaur
    1. Frogadier

    And finally, the most important one, the final forms. Least to greatest:

    18. Charizard
    17. Delphox
    16. Chesnaught
    15. Samurott
    14. Empoleon
    13. Blastoise
    12. Emboar
    11. Feraligatr
    10. Infernape
    9. Typhlosion
    8. Blaziken
    7. Swampert
    6. Meganium
    5. Venusaur
    4. Sceptile
    3. Torterra
    2. Serperior
    1. Greninja

    Yup. Charizard is my least favorite. Please wait until I have my riot shield ready before you start flinging rocks at me.

    *grabs riot shield*

    Okay, now I'm ready.
    "How can you read this? There's no pictures!"

    |No one writes like Gaston!|
    |It's Electric: Cranking it to Eleven || A New Life - For Better or Worse|

  12. #42
    Soon... Herbizarre's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Stalking villagers
    Posts
    710
    Blog Entries
    20

    Follow Herbizarre on Tumblr Visit Herbizarre's Youtube Channel

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    First stage:
    1. Snivy
    2. Mudkip
    3. Squirtle
    4. Bulbasaur
    5. Treecko
    6. Fennekin
    7. Totodile
    8. Charmander
    9. Cyndaquil
    10. Torchic
    11. Piplup
    12. Tepig
    13. Froakie
    14. Turtwig
    15. Chikorita
    16. Chespin
    17. Chimchar
    18. Oshawott

    Second Stage:
    1. Ivysaur
    2. Wartortle
    3. Quilava
    4. Marshtomp
    5. Combusken
    6. Frogadier
    7. Charmeleon
    8. Braixen
    9. Grovyle
    10. Bayleef
    11. Prinplup
    12. Croconaw
    13. Grotle
    14. Quilladin
    15. Servine
    16. Dewott
    17. Monferno
    18. Pignite

    Third Stage
    1. Swampert
    2. Blastoise
    3. Serperior
    4. Sceptile
    5. Blaziken
    6. Typhlosion
    7. Feraligatr
    8. Venusaur
    9. Empoleon
    10. Chesnaught
    11. Greninja
    12. Delphox
    13. Charizard
    14. Torterra
    15. Meganium
    16. Emboar
    17. Samurott
    18. Infernape
    I support : BiologyShipping, GodzillaShipping, GreatRocketShipping, RebelShipping, TransceiverShipping, Fox X Krystal, Leon S. Kennedy X Ada Wong, Leon X Lucy Liberty, FalSam, LGMShipping and Escavalier x Lilligant. This signature image is the perfect place to name all the ships I support without wasting space on the signature, mwa ha ha !
    Click here to view a fanfic of my crossover OTP : Beastman (F-Zero) and Mars (Pokémon).

  13. #43
    Revert & Reverberate Miar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    Planet Miar
    Posts
    1,637
    Blog Entries
    2

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    My chart: Basic, Middle, Final, and Mega

    1. Chespin Quilava Chesnaught M Blaziken
    2. Oshawott Dewott Swampert M Venusaur
    3. Cyndaquil Wartortle Samurott M Charizard X
    4. Fennekin Grovyle Charizard M Blastoise
    5. Totodile Quilladin Typhlosion M Charizard Y
    6. Mudkip Monferno Infernape
    7. Snivy Marshtomp Torterra
    8. Charmander Prinplup Blaziken
    9. Torchic Charmeleon Feraligatr
    10. Bulbasaur Croconaw Greninja
    11. Turtwig Braixen Sceptile
    12. Tepig Bayleef Delphox
    13. Piplup Frogadier Empoleon
    14. Treecko Ivysaur Blastoise
    15. Squirtle Grotle Venusaur
    16. Chimchar Servine Serperior
    17. Froakie Combusken Emboar
    18. Chikorita Pignite Meganium

  14. #44
    You Are (Not) Fine Winterdaze's Avatar Moderator
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    2,569
    Blog Entries
    27

    Follow Winterdaze on Tumblr

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    Quote Originally Posted by Winterdaze View Post
    Final Stage:

    1. Chesnaught
    2. Samurott
    3. Typhlosion
    4. Serperior
    5. Sceptile
    6. Greninja
    7. Venusaur
    8. Empoleon
    9. Torterra
    10. Feraligatr
    11. Emboar
    12. Charizard
    13. Meganium
    14. Blastoise
    15. Blaziken
    16. Delphox
    17. Swampert
    18. Infernape.

    1st Stage:

    1. Chespin
    2. Froakie
    3. Snivy
    4. Totodile
    5. Cyndaquil
    6. Tepig
    7. Turtwig
    8. Squirtle
    9. Bulbasaur
    10. Charmander
    11. Chikorita
    12. Torchic
    13. Fennekin
    14. Piplup
    15. Treecko
    16. Mudkip
    17. Oshawott
    18. Chimchar


    2nd Stage:

    1. Grovyle
    2. Dewott
    3. Servine
    4. Quilava
    5. Quilladin
    6. Frogadier
    7. Braixen
    8. Bayleef
    9. Ivysaur
    10. Wartortle
    11. Charmeleon
    12. Pignite
    13. Grotle
    14. Combusken
    15. Prinplup
    16. Croconaw
    17. Marshtomp
    18. Monferno
    A few changes now that the Kalos starters exist, most notably that the Chespin line is my favourite of all time, not just from the starters. Mega Venusaur also made me like the dinosaur-toad thing a lot more than I used to as well, same with Mega Charizard Y.

  15. #45
    Registered User Odinn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    181

    Default Re: Ranking all the starter Pokemon from best to worst

    With Gen VI starters, the updated list;


    First stage;
    1. Bulbasaur
    2. Chikorita
    3. Squirtle
    4. Charmander
    5. Fennekin
    6. Torchic
    7. Piplup
    8. Treecko
    9. Cyndaquil
    10. Snivy
    11. Froakie
    12. Chespin
    13. Turtwig
    14. Mudkip
    15. Totodile
    16. Chimchar
    17. Oshawott
    18. Tepig

    Second stage;
    1. Quilava
    2. Braixen
    3. Bayleef
    4. Wartortle
    5. Grovyle
    6. Combusken
    7. Monferno
    8. Frogadier
    9. Marshtomp
    10. Servine
    11. Ivysaur
    12. Prinplup
    13. Dewott
    14. Pignite
    15. Charmeleon
    16. Quilladin
    17. Croconaw
    18. Grotle


    Third stage;
    1. Charizard
    2. Sceptile
    3. Blaziken
    4. Blastoise
    5. Typhlosion
    6. Delphox
    7. Greninja
    8. Swampert
    9. Empoleon
    10. Chesnaught
    11. Infernape
    12. Serperior
    13. Meganium
    14. Feraligatr
    15. Venusaur
    16. Torterra
    17. Samurott
    18. Emboar


    Megas;
    1. Blastoise
    2. Charizard Y / Charizard X
    3. Charizard X / Charizard Y
    4. Blaziken

    5. Venusaur

Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •