Hi everyone! I'm actually trying out this thread topic as an artistic project for the community here. If it takes off well and people like it a lot, then I'll probably end up pinning the topic so that it doesn't get buried underneath all the other threads.
Oh... and before anyone asks for tutorials for specific colouring, lining or just general PhotoShop/GIMP/SAI/Painter methods, there is a thread here for that. If there isn't a tutorial of what you're looking for, let me know and I'll do my best to look up something for you and anyone else that may want it. C:
Anyways, that aside.... The point of this thread is for artists to help other artists out there. Well, those that are willing to offer it. I wanted artists -- beginning and the more seasoned -- to come to this thread to receive and offer help. If there are artists out there that are looking for critique from other artists, then they can post the art that they want to have critiqued by others (note: people that critique art, colour and composition don't necessarily have to be artists themselves to point out things that can be improved) and ask questions about their art that they would like to have answered.
There are two types of critique that the people willing to offer critique can use. Either the red line assistance, or just flat out pointing them out through words. I will say that red lining for someone while describing what they could do to make it better is generally a better course of assistance for the artist. Mainly because they get a visual on how it's supposed to look and, thus, do have a goal for what their anatomy should look like.
As a general note, I must let everyone know that this thread is not for people that can't handle people showing them errors in their work (which would actually make a majority of us question just why you posted in this thread in the first place). If you're really wanting the help that other people are offering, please don't get offended by the way someone just says something is 'off' about your art.
Then to the people that are offering critique and assistance to the new artists -- while I know that critiques aren't meant to be ego-stoking, super nice sets of words... do make it so that you don't come across as a total jerk. We want to encourage people to continue doing art and to get better, not wanting to hole themselves up artistically. There is a way to make a nice sounding critique, so please keep it so that it sounds and reads as such.