
Originally Posted by
Gotpika
Did not expect Aporon, Ina, and Josef to manage a clean 3-0 sweep of them. I think it's good though since it builds up a little more animosity and turmoil within the group, Thatcher for example and his being bullied by Josef and Aporon's superiority complex over Fritz.
Surprised you didn't bring up the one-upsmanship that seemed to be going on between Josef and Aporon. It's in-passing, but it is there.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
Ina and Reika's interactions are a special case, Ina came off as completely friendly and harmless while Reika came off as more of an antagonist so you got me curious on what type of past these two have.
IIRC, Legacy helped me with this one way way back. Since Reika is pretty much an antagonistic person herself, and we've already seen the likes of Liane and Irene who are worse (although they weren't originally in the plan), I decided to create the opposite character for a rival - someone ditzy, cheerful, likeable, better looking, and generally pleasant.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
Really starting to wonder if Thatcher is an inexperienced trainer, compared to Reika and Fritz he has no evolved Pokemon and is going for Contest. Plus he seems to have a sense of up-and-coming about him with his flaws like his stage fright and softness.
Oh, it gets more interesting than that. ;)

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
Moving on to the Aporon battle, it felt a bit dragged out near the end with the constant attack exchanging with no one falling.
I'm a little sad at two people thus far saying this, to be honest. I was trying to write something quite different from the norm there - a more suspenseful, slow-paced, and methodical battle. It makes sense in-context, too - Huntail would be no match for Skuntank in a head-on fight, so Fritz used careful, patient tactics. There will be more of those to come, though I do feel the need to mention they're generally the exception and not the rule. There'll also be fast-paced and suspenseful, as well as battles that are just longer in general.
Battle psychology is a factor even in "normal" fights. It helps to be able to really get into the moment, which is part of the reason why I went for present tense.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
The thing I loved about this was, drum roll please, the mystery member of Fritz's team was revealed to be a Huntail. Your previous descriptions of it have been so cryptic and welly placed it was a genuine surprise to find out what it was. Knew it couldn't be a Gyarados, too small so I was thinking Dratini and then tried to remember if Dratini can learn any water-expelling attacks so didn't have a clue what it was.
It's like I said before - no one really expects Huntail, which kinda speaks volumes about it as a Pokemon. :P Also, Dratini and Dragonair don't have a toothy jaw, which is more of an issue than water-moves.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
I also noticed how when threatened Aporon's calm and mature demeanor gradually began to chip away and he faltered into an arrogant, screaming wreck who wouldn't let Fritz get one word out. It was a really entertaining chapter, subtle character development, and a few twist.
Aporon's views on battles are like yours - he's most comfortable with them being faster-paced and more straight-up. Basically, what most would consider normal. This also reveals why Muriel Palmoni may be such a huge threat to him. From his perspective though, can you really blame him for lashing out like that? What Aporon thought was going to be a quick and simple reality check for his mentee got turned on its ear. It'll be touched on a little more in coming chapters, though.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
For a second I thought Inara was her Wigglytuff's nickname before I realized it's Ina's full name, might wanna make it a little more clearer. Why would Reika suddenly call her Inara too when she's been calling her Ina all day?
Noted. Although, I dunno if you read/remember 2-1, but Reika actually first called her "Inara", though did use "Ina" later on. Same thing happens in 2-2.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
I personally think this can be delivered much better so it doesn't come off as text dump-y. Nothing wrong with text dumping at times, just remember it might be a bit more effective in some scenes to take a little description and intermix it with normal actions.
Another text dump, once in a while it's okay but with the description of every never-before-seen Pokemon it gets a bit reductive and to be a chore.
I'll keep that in mind from now on, thanks.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
"Nicknames are stupid and so are you!" Reika screamed. "Wigglytuff, Body Slam!"
Just another example of how funny Reika's attitude can be at times.
TBH, it's actually partially her acting as my voice. >_>

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
Nice world-building
I was looking for a way to exposition these sorts of things. I decided a battle Fritz was watching would be perfect for it.

Originally Posted by
Gotpika
"Whoa." Reika said. This is the first time I've managed to amaze her. I smiled a little on the inside.
Tsundere-ish scene? :P
Wait, from Fritz or Reika? Either way...wait, I'm not sure if there's a point where this reaction gets (can get) explained further later. But there probably is.
Bookmarks