Take Dawn off and Bring May Back! - Blogs - Bulbagarden Forums

View RSS Feed

MetaRobo's Dark Matter Reactor

Take Dawn off and Bring May Back!

Rate this Entry
by , 13th July 2008 at 01:51 PM (1181 Views)
Did I catch your attention?

Strangely, people expressing this sentiment are a mere wisp in the Pokemon fandom, especially considering how nasty the Anti-May rhetoric was back in the good old days when Misty had just left the cast, and even now, the Bring Misty Back lot far overpowers the Bring May back lot. Personally, I wouldn't be able to stand having every other anime forum post being about how Dawn sucks and May should come back, despite May being my favourite character (okay, my favourite character is Breloom, but we're talking homo sapiens here), but the absence of the madness is curious.

I suppose some snarky Bulbagardeners will say that no one cared about May. Um... 800,000+ views for an Advanceshipping video on Youtube (http://bmgf.bulbagarden.net/www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8COx7Wn7mM) is no mean feat. Even snarkier fans will claim that people only cared about her breasts. Well, I suppose that would explain how the infamous horny Misty fanbase mysteriously vanished off the radar with the advent of Advance, but that's another story. Although my response to that argument is purely anecdotal, I do know many people that passionately followed May's story, a good deal of them even female. Yes, indeed I am fairly upset that the reaction to May's departure here was similar to the reaction when the Death Star was blown up, but this is no time to discuss my vendetta.

The reaction to May's departure among her fanbase is interesting. Many of them were more accepting then vengeful (once again, anecdotal, but I have noticed this trend). They were happy that May could become strong independent from Ash. I guess that a satisfying conclusion goes a long way in abetting manaical "Bring Character Back" attempts. Even the ones that do want May back on the main cast convey a mood more of hopefulness or resignation rather than vindictiveness. I suppose that the rampant May bashing years ago turned them off that sort of attitude.

Do I want May back? Of course. Will I attempt to start some mad campaign to do it? No. I respect the writers' decision, and there's more to life than bringing back a character on a children's TV show. In fact, just because my favourite human character is gone doesn't mean I can't still enjoy it, although I do hope that they let Brock retire for a few seasons next time rather than introduce a new girl just to satisfy desperately horny Nintendo fans deprived of the erotic women of other franchises such as Dead or Alive or Soul Calibur, or even other anime shows. Even Advanceshipping is not an adequate reason to bring May back, because Ash and May can always keep each other in their hearts even when far apart. And it could have been worse. The show could have ended right there, or May could have received an anticlimactic conclusion which would crush any hints of her returning.

Submit "Take Dawn off and Bring May Back!" to Digg Submit "Take Dawn off and Bring May Back!" to del.icio.us Submit "Take Dawn off and Bring May Back!" to StumbleUpon Submit "Take Dawn off and Bring May Back!" to Google

Updated 1st August 2008 at 09:33 PM by MetaRobo (Less harsh title)

Categories
Rant

Comments

  1. ferrari-kun187's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    O_o....I think the "kill Dawn" part was a bit intense.
  2. MetaRobo's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Sorry, that was sarcastic. It's a hyperbole with the intent of mocking the Bring Misty Back lot, because this was the level of rhetoric they used. I don't actually mean it, but I'll tone down the title.
    Updated 13th July 2008 at 11:28 PM by MetaRobo
  3. Lilac Hill's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    No, don't.

    Edit: Too late, you already changed it.
    Updated 14th July 2008 at 01:11 AM by Lilac Hill
  4. ferrari-kun187's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Ah, I actually had a crush on May when I was 10 years old. weird aint it? I'd agree that May should rejoin the team again without Dawn leaving.
  5. The Outrage's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    I think YTV just said "screw it" to the rest of the BF saga so I never saw May leave. Also:

    Take [insert 5th gen girl] off, bring Dawn back!

    Just wanted to be one of the first.
  6. Quartzthyst's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    lol, nice one Outrage. I also find the boobies part a little bit.. meh? Like c'mon, they weren't even that big.

    /me runs
  7. The Outrage's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    big for a ten year old, if you actually think she's ten.
  8. Maybe Wednesday's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Bring May back! Pleeez!
  9. Yamato-san's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Quote Originally Posted by Outrage
    big for a ten year old, if you actually think she's ten.
    you also forgot that in proportion to the rest of her body, they're actually quite something (though it's never actually consistent in the animation, especially later on, but damn were they big on a number of occasions ^^).

    It's characters like Haruka that make me wish to ignore age in hentai and focus only on how the bodily form was drawn (though conversely, there are characters in their late teens/early 20s who resemble a loli... not particularly hot, but I have seen it result in some interesting storylines XD). It's all fiction anyway. ^^
  10. Dogasu's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    "If you actually think she's ten."

    Um...I'm pretty sure the very first episode of Advanced Generation establishes her age.

    Also, I never saw what the big deal with Haruka's chest was. Just like I don't see the big deal with Hikari's supposed "panty shots."
  11. Yamato-san's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Quote Originally Posted by Dogasu
    "If you actually think she's ten."

    Um...I'm pretty sure the very first episode of Advanced Generation establishes her age.

    Also, I never saw what the big deal with Haruka's chest was. Just like I don't see the big deal with Hikari's supposed "panty shots."
    I think you're familiar enough with the fandom to know that people have been skeptical of that line from day one (even if most of them are just ignorant of how early early bloomers can actually be).

    And I don't see the big deal with Hikari's skirt either... I like her hair, though (hair in Pokemon that's actually animated? WhOMG! 0.0).

Trackbacks

Total Trackbacks 0
Trackback URL: