Celebrity Grass-type Specialists - winstein's Review - Blogs - Bulbagarden Forums

View RSS Feed

winstein's Blogs

Celebrity Grass-type Specialists - winstein's Review

Rate this Entry
by , 24th March 2011 at 07:42 AM (4547 Views)

(By Loveon)

(Note: If the 25000 character limit was still in place, I would never have written it this long.)


And here we are, about to investigate the Grass-type specialists. The reason I didn’t do an “Ordinary trainer classes” version of the Grass-type is there’s only one trainer class that qualified in that list, so instead, I went straight for the celebrities. Alright, enough introduction; let’s move on!



Erika
The Nature-Loving Princess



"Hello... Lovely weather, isn't it? It's so pleasant... I'm afraid I might doze off... My name is Erika.
I am the Leader of Celadon Gym. ...Oh? You are from Johto, you say? How nice... Oh. I'm sorry, I didn't
realize that you wished to challenge me. I know. I have been training myself on not only flower
arrangement but also Pokémon battle. I shall not lose." ~ Erika

"Our Leader Erika might be quiet, but she’s famous around here." ~ Lass Lola in Celadon Gym

"Erika is the kind of girl that defines traditional beauty and gives off an aura of cuteness but
also toughness at the same time. Her tendency to doze off is also endearing." ~ Ranger Jack Walker

"Sorry Erika, as pure and sweet as you are, you just bring a new meaning to "nasty slab of meat"
that is too-literal for my tastes. " ~ System Error




Every trainer in Kanto is based on some kind of stereotype, like Misty being based on a swimmer and Blaine the scientist (I am not sure about Brock but I think he’s a builder in Red and Blue). As for Erika, she’s obviously a Japanese beauty (or a princess). Maybe if she has a Leafeon, she can join the Kimono Sisters gang who possesses Eeveelutions, but I am sure there’s more to her than that one-shot posse. Normally, she’s the fourth Gym Leader, but the non-linearity when it comes to Gym clearance in Kanto meant that it may not be true. Still, beat her in a battle and win a Rainbow Badge.

Erika definitely shows that she loves kimonos, but I felt that her sense of fashion is too bland and doesn’t stand up to this era’s trend, because it doesn’t have a lot of standouts. Also, I felt Erika’s beauty is also not my type, because her cuteness is not that interesting, to be honest. However, I do credit that simplicity in a time (I think it happens now as well) when video game characters are striving to have extreme fashion choices.

Erika demonstrates the behaviour of dozing off at times, which I am guessing is supposed to make her look cute, since I can see how cute girls sleeping are cute in a way. One theory about this is how the Grass-types usually have sleeping powder, so that would explain the narcolepsy. Erika is also implied to be a quiet person, and I think it’s because silence is golden, because if Erika is chattier (like another Erika from Medabots), maybe she wouldn’t be as attractive to the Easterns, and Erika is clearly a Japanese lady.

As for talents, Erika also demonstrates the art of flower-arranging, and from hearing this, I am led to believe that she just arrange them as bouquets. However, I like to see the term used for plantation, because to me, this form of flower arrangement is more attractive than bouquets, since those are highly temporary compared to planting them. It also never appeared that Erika took up gardening, so that’s too bad.

There are some cards that might have told us about Erika. Erika’s Maids may imply that she is rich and can afford the maids to do her bidding. Erika’s Kindness, Good Manners and Charity show that she has the virtue of benevolence. And well, Erika’s Perfume is pretty much what she is known for, especially in the anime. Aromatherapy is a Grass-type status move, so it should make sense for scent to be used from the Grass-types. One such Grass-type family is the Gloom family. However, Gloom is based on the rafflesia, a flower that has a pungent smell, which wouldn’t make a good scent, but that’s what Erika used to make the perfume, so I wouldn’t complain since it’s implied to be sweet anyway.

In the manga, Erika is one of the good Gym Leaders and being the leader of the Gym Leaders (Wow! What a change of pace!). Reading about Erika’s stories in the ‘pedia is really interesting, because it seems that despite her looks, she does a lot of stuff, like practicing archery and defending Celadon City from Lorelei. In the anime, however, Erika’s only featured in an episode, where her posse refused to let Ash at the Gym for disrespecting their property. Not as interesting, but still OK.

Erika’s Pokémon group consists of mainly Grass-types, obviously. The games gave her different Pokémon, but generally, Tangela is kept, which is great, because Tangela is one of my favourite Grass-types. In the Generation 1 and 3 games, she has both version exclusive Grass-types (Weepinbell and Gloom in Yellow and the anime, and Victreebel and Vileplume elsewhere). Generation 2 gave her Jumpluff and Bellossom (which if going by Yellow and the anime’s canon, makes sense) in her arsenal. HeartGold and SoulSilver’s ability to have Gym Leaders request rematches allowed her team to be expanded. Her team is centred on the use of Sunny Day, and five of her new lineup has Chlorophyll, in which one of them is Tangela – I mean Tangrowth. That’s right, if you noticed, her Tangela in the remake has AncientPower, which is what Tangela needs to evolve. Her new Pokémon not featured before are Shiftry and Roserade, who are both decent Pokémon in the own right, and they are featured in Generation 3 and 4 respectively.

Erika mentioned how she wouldn’t collect Pokémon she deemed unattractive, which will probably be biased, because not every Grass-type is attractive. I guess she will not like to have Amoonguss and Ferrothorn, as those Pokémon are generally deemed as hideous. Ironically, those two Pokémon are great Grass-types in competitive battling.

I like how Erika demonstrated different roles across the media, with her flower-arranging activity in the games, perfume business in the anime and generally her leadership in the manga, and all of them still preserved their Gym Leader status. Erika may not look attractive to me, but it’s her qualities that count that make her great.


8 kimonos out of 10!





Gardenia
Master of Vivid Plant Pokémon



"You kept me waiting! I'm Eterna's Gym Leader, Gardenia, the Grass-type master! When I first saw you,
I was convinced you'd find your way to me. My hunch was right on the money. You have a winning aura about you.
So, anyway, this will be fun. Let's have our battle." ~ Gardenia

"She's the second gym leader of the Sinnoh region and already she uses some of the top Pokemon of
the generation (Roserade and Torterra). She has a fair amount of characterization and her gym's design has
one of the most creative puzzles seen in Pokemon history. Energetic but graceful, Gardenia is certainly one of the best
gym leaders GameFreak has ever created." ~ Envoy

"Gardenia is the most awesome gym leader ever. Her hair is awesome, her clothes are awesome, her Pokemon
are awesome, and she looks awesome when her eyes turn to hearts when she looks at a grass type =D" ~ Gardenia101




In Diamond, Pearl and Platinum, Gardenia is the second Gym you will encounter in your journey, where you will get your Forest Badge. If the player went for Chimchar, this wouldn’t be a problem, but because I never chose Chimchar for my starter (I boxed that ape in the PC before even the first gym), I have somewhat of a hard time, as I only had Bidoof and Cleffa with me. Enough of my story; moving on!

Gardenia’s sense of fashion is, in my opinion, much better than Erika. I feel that Gardenia’s is a more natural fit for a Grass-type, because her style is more nature-oriented. Her umbrella-like hair is something I like, and that poncho of hers looks natural because it looks like a leaf worn over her body and it’s not a shirt. She also wears cargo shorts and boots, which are great for the great outdoors, so this means she generally travel outdoors. Generally, I am more pleased with her fashion choices, since it’s more exotic and tough at the same time. Maybe some think she has “tomboy” vibes, but I don’t think that’s necessarily true.

Gardenia’s main Pokémon is clearly Roserade, who is one of the new evolutions in Generation 4. This is so because that Pokémon is clearly the strongest Pokémon when you battled her, as her other Pokémon are Turtwig and Cherubi, both basic-staged Pokémon (she had Cherrim in Platinum, but that’s not her strongest). When you have a rematch with her at the Battleground, you can bet that her team undergone some changes. First of all, her team’s fully-evolved, and she has two new additions: Bellossom and Jumpluff. Those two Pokémon are also Erika’s additions in the Generation 2 games. I would have gone for more interesting suggestions, but I suppose that if the designers wanted those choices, they can do it.

One thing I find amusing is while I say “Bring it on!” for a Grass/Ghost combination, Gardenia is like “What then?”, implying her uncertainty, which is because she is implied to have fear of ghosts, as evidenced by her words at the Old Chateau near Eterna City. In fact, I can see why she has Shadow Ball on Roserade as well as Crunch on Torterra. Speaking of that, it would be interesting if this Grass/Ghost Pokémon has some immense benefits over other Grass-types besides the Ghost-type, like maybe immunity to Fire or have the ability Thick Fat, which could be qualities that will win her over.

Anyway, in the anime her obsession with Grass-types is wilder than Erika (some scenes depicted this as...exaggerating). Also, James gave her his Cacnea he caught in the same episode as Weezing’s departure, in order that it mastered Drain Punch, which was revealed to be successful. She also appeared to have more than the selection there, as she is mentioned to have Bellossom, Victreebel and Vileplume, which were version exclusive Grass-types in Generation 1 (especially the last two).

As for the manga, she is shown to also have a fear of ghosts, as was mentioned when she was supposed to investigate the Old Chateau nearby. The manga also demonstrates something I am generally not satisfied with the type chart, because there, a Water-type used an Ice attack on her Pokémon. Maybe I shouldn’t root for the main character because of that, so...yeah.

Alright, what I have to say about Gardenia is somewhat opposite from Erika. Gardenia has the looks and the fashion, but in terms of activity, she is the lesser, because I don’t recall her being fit, which I am to believe from the way she dressed (cargo pants and boots!). Maybe her top portion is not suited for that kind of activity, but I thought it’s really disappointing, though, because if she looked fit, then this would break the mould for girls, since the main ones are skinny and not muscular.


8 ponchos out of 10!





Cilan
Triple Trouble



"Nothing personal... No hard feelings... Me and my Grass-type Pokémon will...um... We're gonna battle come what may. (...)
So, um, if you're OK with me, I'll, um, put everything I've got into being, er, you know, your opponent." ~ Cilan

"I was afraid that he was going to act over the top and flamboyant for the entirety of the [anime] series,
and it would get overwhelming...But to me, he's already proven himself to have a multi-faceted personality.
I really enjoy his kindness, over-confidence, arrogance, passion in his profession and sometimes
teasing behavior. When he yells, "It's tasting time!" ("Time for the battle to be served!" in the dub),
you know that s***'s about to go down.

With the writers giving him more focus as the series goes on, I can't help but be affected by his charm
even more! Keep on tasting, valiant sommelier :) " ~ CommanderPigg

"Cilan is one of those characters you either love or hate. With his flamboyant and amusing personality and
extravagant design he is definitely a character to try out. Props for having a great dynamic with the trio he
belongs to and for being a breath of fresh air in what the anime's main male characters are concerned. " ~ ghaskan

"One thing I like about Cilan is the lack of running gag to be honest. I feel that we see different sides to him
in different episodes and that's interesting. (...) he was effervescent, (...) he felt almost like a caring older sibling,
(...) he was playfully mocking [Axew]'s Dragon Sneeze with Ash, we saw him bond with [Dwebble], (...) he was very scientific
and (...) we saw a bit of his competitive side, a bit of arrogance and a hint of a dark side. " ~ Hellion




And the next one on the list happens to be the only male character here, so it’s a breath of fresh air since he’s the only one that looks different because of that. Cilan is basically the Gym Leader of Striaton City, which is the first place with a gym in it. Do note that Cilan’s review will be longer that the last two people (and the next one), so brace yourselves!

Cilan, unlike the previous two, doesn’t have the same fashion sense (being a guy and all), instead going for something simpler, which is to dress formally as a waiter. In fact, his two brothers also have the same idea, but they agreed that they should have different hairstyles, bowties and faces, otherwise you can’t tell who is who. However simple he may dress, it’s surprising very effective, because not only does he look very elegant, he’s got the hots for the ladies as well (as the anime and the forums have shown). Cilan’s green eyes, green bowtie and green, grass-like hair is a match for his type specialty, but he lacked the sclera that pretty much everyone has, which makes him seems like the odd one out, but I imagine that he looks more handsome and calm because of this (especially the last one).

Cilan’s Pokémon selection is appropriately limited for a first Gym, in which he only has Pansage and Lillipup (only Pansage in the anime). This is not particularly impressive (though understandable), but thankfully, he’s not limited to them in the anime, since he should have been able to get more Pokémon in the journey. So far, Dwebble is the only one he got, which shows that type diversity is necessary and entertaining. There’s hope that the third version will provide Cilan with a wider variety of Pokémon in a rematch, though. To Cilan credit though...he is only up for battle when Oshawott is chosen (the starter that is weak to his main Pokémon), presenting a challenge to the player. However, if they chose to get a Pansear in the Dreamyard, that’s another story.

In terms of personality, Cilan is shown to be meek and afraid to offend others, which would be a reflection of the type, as brothers Chili and Cress has both a fiery and smooth personality respectively. Somehow, I felt that the subdued personality is something that girls like, because he seemed incomplete as far as character goes. However, his personality isn’t like this in the anime. Over there, he never shows any signs of meekness, but instead, he’s more flamboyant, arrogant and outgoing (and maybe sinister too, but we will get to that later), which is the Cilan we are more familiar with. Did I mention that he loves to speak things plant-related?

Cilan’s more well-known in the anime, so I believe that a larger portion of this review will be dedicated to it. In the anime, Cilan is a Pokémon Connoisseur, or in the Japanese version, a Pokémon Sommelier. Basically what Cilan does is to compare a Pokémon’s compatibility with their trainers, which he did when he first met Ash and Iris, in a similar way a connoisseur judge art or even food based on taste, quality and authenticity. It certainly is a more fitting description than sommelier, which is usually associated with wines. Speaking of that, there is a popular line by Cilan in the Japanese version, where he said “It’s tasting time!”, which I think is funny, but to some it’s campy. As for the English version, Cilan mentioned the less dramatic “It’s time for the battle to be served!”.

In “Triple Leaders, Team Threats”, he met Ash and Iris in the streets of Striaton City, where he was impressed by both of their partner Pokémon Axew and Pikachu, especially the latter. Shortly after this, Ash was sent to a restaurant, which also happens to be where the gym is held (like the games), although there is no quiz involved to get to them. Like the games, Cilan battled Ash’s Oshawott (his pseudo starter), which he got from Professor Juniper from request. After Ash’s victory, Cilan began to take a liking on Ash, and when that time came, Cilan decided that he wanted to travel with Ash, which means we have ourselves another travelling partner in Unova.

During the travels, we get to learn more about Cilan as the episodes gone by. Cilan is revealed to be a very good chef, where he prepared food for the main heroes with equipment you never thought he will carry in his small bag. He is also rather sceptical to anything mystical, which is rather strange because this is the Pokémon World, where mystical things can happen. In fact, Cilan seems like a contrast to Iris, who believes in the more mystical stuff, and the fact that Cilan is the urban boy and Iris being the rural girl. It sort of hits him back when he was possessed by a Yamask’ mask. Cilan’s also a rather experienced person, where his knowledge in Pokémon is really broad. In fact, it must be the reason he’s a Class A connoisseur, which is the second-highest.

Amusingly, Cilan’s English voice is Sonic’s previous voice actor Jason Griffith, which I find funny, because I imagine that if Cilan says something similar to “Sonic’s my name, speed’s my game”, there will be someone out there fawning over his words (maybe something like “Cilan’s my name, tasting’s my game!”). I really liked the thought that Ash is travelling with Sonic around Unova, and it definitely is something to compare with Sonic and Chris Thorndyke. Cilan’s Japanese voice actor is also popular, since he’s the voice actor of the famous villain protagonist Light Yagami, which raised the theory within the fandom that Cilan got more screen time because of that celebrity status. Oh, and there are two particular scenes that made Cilan looked not only out of the ordinary for him, but made him a lot cooler? Instead of explaining, I will just show you the two scenes I am referring to:



Something I really love about Cilan is how he always dressed formal to wherever he goes, which is something I did not expect. I thought he will have an exclusive travelling outfit when he’s not in the gym, but he sure loves his attire a lot, and the best part is that it never seems to wear and tear, even when exposed to destruction like Axew’s Dragon Rage. Another thing I liked about him is how well he’s handled. To tell you the truth, I never thought that Cilan will even be remotely interesting, but good to know that I am wrong here. Before I forget, I was surprised to see that Cilan's quite a tall guy (I assumed that he was going to only be slightly taller than Ash).

Thanks to promotion to being the main character in the anime, Cilan is much more appreciated as a character. This is great, because it seems to me that the manga only gave Cilan appearances only within the gym battle. Because there is yet a breadth of anime to go, whatever said here will be less and less complete as the series goes on. However, for now, I would say that Cilan’s one of the best things that happens to the Grass-type in Generation 5, because as Ash’s travelling partner, expect to see him more in the episodes to come.


9 bowties out of 10!





Nikki
Flower Power



"I am Nikki, the Grass Club Master. What? You were looking for me? Oh my… I’m very sorry to keep you waiting.
I was doing a little research here. I assume you would like to duel? I only duel at the Club. I’m sorry, but
could you meet me at the Grass Club? I will head back to the Grass Club and I wait for you there. " ~ Nikki

"Nikki has some awesome potential in her deck. She has two formidable Grass Pokemon, Venusaur
and Exeggutor, and together, they may be able to defeat you. " ~ nucleargamer12 (Gamefaqs)




Finally, we have Nikki, who only made her appearance in the TCG video game, where she is the Club Master of the Grass club. Technically she’s not a trainer, but since she specialise in the Grass-types with her deck, she’s in this group. Like Erika, her club is an all-female cast.

When first going into the club, you won’t see her there, but only two of her members nearby. In order to meet her, you must first battle her cohorts, defeating them at least once each. Remember that she has three cohorts, where two are in the grass portion, and one is in the lounge. If you managed to defeat them all, you would go to Ishihara’s house (which I guessed is named after the TCG’s designer) to meet Nikki. She will then return to the club, where you can battle her. Beat her, and you can claim the Grass Medal.

Nikki herself looks like a typical teacher, which I guess isn’t what she do, but I thought that her carrying a book and wearing a collared shirt suggested this. However, she is said to be a researcher as well, since she was doing research at Ishihara’s house. Because none of the characters are fleshed out in the TCG video game (with the probably exception of Ronald, your rival), it’s hard to see her character.

Her deck’s strategy is, as you would expect, focused on the Grass-types. It has the Bulbasaur families, Oddish families (no Bellossom) and Exeggcute families. The three fully-evolved Pokémon provide some synergy with each other, since they are all pretty hard-hitters, and they all have can perform a certain role. Vileplume provides some healing with its Pokémon Power, as it can be done every turn. Exeggutor is perhaps the one you need to look out for, for if it manages to get hold of a lot of Energy Cards (because each Energy does a potential 20 damage), it might even be able to KO the Defending Pokémon (a term used for the opponent’s Active Pokémon that is attacked), not to mention the ability to get out of the scene when the going got tough. Venusaur is used for his Energy Trans Pokémon Power, which is used to be able to move the Grass Energy around for strategic purposes, like dumping all on Exeggutor for a potentially one-shot KO. That’s not to say the other members should be ignored, as they all can be dangerous too. Gloom and Ivysaur are able to Poison the Defending Pokémon, Bulbasaur and Exeggcute can use Leech Seed to be able to sustain their survivability, Exeggcute can Sleep the opponent too, and Oddish can multiply and paralyse.

All in all, Nikki is just alright, with her reasonable physical appearance and a decent deck, but her lack of real character may have hurt. Still, I do like her, because she has somewhat green hair and a round face.


7 books out of 10!





Looking at this one compared to the Ghost-type version of the review that I did last time, I can say that the there are so many changes that you should see for yourselves to compare. Anyway, with this done, I officially conclude the Grass-type reviews I have made, which not surprisingly, took a long time to complete from start to finish. If there’s a Generation 6, you can be sure that I will review the Grass-types introduced in that period, but for now, this is the final one. There are two “refreshments” after the end of the line, so be sure to check them out if you can. I hope you enjoyed reading this entry as much as I have writing them.

Thanks for reading, everyone.
I appreciate it.




Bouquet time!


Fan Art Time!
(Warning: Contains large images!)
Kakuna Matata likes this.

Submit "Celebrity Grass-type Specialists - winstein's Review" to Digg Submit "Celebrity Grass-type Specialists - winstein's Review" to del.icio.us Submit "Celebrity Grass-type Specialists - winstein's Review" to StumbleUpon Submit "Celebrity Grass-type Specialists - winstein's Review" to Google

Updated 25th March 2011 at 10:17 AM by winstein (Added an intro picture)

Categories
Reviews , Grass Entries

Comments

  1. Karamazov's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Great read as always.
  2. Ranger Jack Walker's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Gardenia is a truly horrible name :P
  3. winstein's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Quote Originally Posted by Ranger Jack Walker
    Gardenia is a truly horrible name :P
    Gardenia is also the brand name of bread in my country. But then, I don't have an opinion on her name.

    Thanks for reading.
  4. Kutomba's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Quote Originally Posted by Ranger Jack Walker
    Gardenia is a truly horrible name :P
    -.- IT'S AWESOME!

    Great job, I enjoyed it! ^^
  5. Kyuuketsuki's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    How have I not seen this blog before? Quite an enjoyable read. *subscribes*
  6. Mijzelffan's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    In my opinion Cilan should just get all fully evolved grass starters and Simisage. And then his brothers would get the counterparts. That's kinda the only reason, to make the bro's all get their respective types from trio's :3
  7. winstein's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Quote Originally Posted by Mijzelffan
    In my opinion Cilan should just get all fully evolved grass starters and Simisage. And then his brothers would get the counterparts. That's kinda the only reason, to make the bro's all get their respective types from trio's :3
    I see. That's an interesting idea! If all of the starters (plus monkeys) have some synergy supporting each other, I would be be even more impressed.

    Thanks for reading.
  8. Owain's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    awesome reads, i prefer Erika over Gardenia on design, but that's just me
  9. Super Seaking's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Good read as always.

    Gosh, that one picture with Cilan serving Rankys pre-evolution is really creepy.
  10. GengarEatBanana's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Good job as always. Keep it up.
  11. Kakuna Matata's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    You never cease to amaze me on the amount of time, effort and quality you put into each review. Bravo!
  12. Grass Type Warrior's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Quote Originally Posted by winstein
    I see. That's an interesting idea! If all of the starters (plus monkeys) have some synergy supporting each other, I would be be even more impressed.

    Thanks for reading.
    Actually, they kinda do, since each Grass Starter fills a different role in a party (as opposed to the Fire and Water counterparts.) Venusaur is the balanced one, Meganium is the supporter, Sceptile is the special attacker, Torterra is the physical attacker and Serperior is the tank.

    Great review as always.
  13. Fennel's Avatar
    • |
    • permalink
    Nice review, this is a blog I'll keep an eye on ^^

Trackbacks

Total Trackbacks 0
Trackback URL: